Home  
  About  
  Americas  
  Global  
  Iraq  
  Palestine  
  Zionism  
  Stooges  
  Video  
  Blog  
  Links  
  • Israel's "new Middle East"*
  • "According to security sources"
  • Behind the smokescreen of the Gaza pullout*
  • From The Hague to Mas'ha*
  • The long road home
  • "You and I and the next war"
  • The great experiment
  • Israel's missed opportunities for peace (partial list)
  • A four-letter word
  • To talk with Hamas
  • A massacre foretold
  • For whom the bells toll
  • "God wills it!"
  • Vanunu: the terrible secret
  • Ehud Barak: a villa in the jungle
  • Pioneers of terrorism
  • Myth-based propaganda
  • A quick guide to the Palestine-Israel conflict
  • In clear sight of Yad Vashem
  • Europe, Israel and the Palestinians
  • Checkpoints and house demolitions
  • The power of saying no
  • Sharon - the end of an era?
  • State land, state people
  • The return of Palestinian refugees is an existential necessity for Israeli Jews
  • Israel's use of terrorist tactics
  • Summer rains and Saad
  • Bickering while Rome burns
  • Inshallah
  • A vision of Palestine
  • Peace work and virtual Palestine
  • Tsunami in Gaza, celebration of peace in Jerusalem
  • Pussycat
  • Kidnap of BBC reporter Alan Johnston
  • Blood on our hands
  • The Livni-Rice Plan
  • Exercise in escapism
  • Flushing out the traitors and criminals in our midst
  • The people of Palestine must seize power now
  • On generals and admirals
  • Crocodile tears
  • Hope at the edge of the precipice
  • Saving Mahmoud Abbas
  • The dirty word
  • Israel keeping on a steady course to apartheid
  • An Israeli love story
  • A stupid war
  • A trap for fools
  • White elephants
  • Not only territory, but viability
  • Saying no to the hunters of Goliath
  • A bruised reed
  • Medical conditions caused by political decisions
  • The Palestinian Mandela
  • So, what is different about the village of Wadi Fuqeen?
  • Revisiting the partition of Palestine
  • Say it with flowers
  • How to get out?
  • Between apartheid and the status quo
  • The right to our Palestinian land must be restored
  • Separate but unequal in Palestine
  • O'Bethlehem
  • Will peace cost me my home?
  • A generous offer to the Palestinian refugees?
  • How they stole the bomb from us
  • Non-stop ethnic cleansing
  • Torture and torment in 2007 AD
  • Israel's Palestinians speak out
  • See Gaza and weep
  • Prerequisites for peace between Israel and Palestinians
  • Help! A cease-fire!
  • The case of the White Bird
  • The hands of Esau
  • Israel paralysing Christianity in Holy Land
  • This time next year?
  • Worse than a crime
  • The strangulation of Gaza
  • An end foreseen
  • Blood and champagne
  • Is Israel using prohibited “thermobarbaric” weapons in its holocaust?
  • The right to equate Gaza with Auschwitz
  • How Israel taught Hamas all it knows
  • "Kill a hundred Turks and rest..."
  • Gaza's “bigger holocaust”
  • Gaza: Oxfam has the answer
  • Photos of the sea
  • "I came, I saw, I destroyed!"
  • The “rogue entity”
  • Manifest destiny?
  • Jewish settlers flood Palestinian neighbours with sewage
  • Good for Carter
  • Time is running out for Israel*
  • The ongoing Nakba
  • With friends like these...
  • Will Gaza ever get a whiff of its offshore gas?
  • Land of Hope and Glory
  • Escaping forward
  • Grabbing Jerusalem's bread and water
  • Ehud Olmert’s Syrian peace spin
  • Palestinians must learn media skills
  • Palestinian envoy to Britain told to be more proactive
  • Israel deporting Jerusalem Christians
  • Who needs enemies?
  • Tactics that ended apartheid in South Africa can end it in Israel
  • Occupation by bureaucracy
  • A mission to uphold the law
  • When guilt turns red
  • Détente or hidden agendas?
  • A West Bank town’s fight to survive
  • "If I forget thee, Umm Touba..."
  • Palestinian family denied even half a house 
  • The powerful own the law
  • The struggle against Jerusalem’s quiet ethnic cleansing
  • Breaking the Gaza siege
  • Truth and consequences under the Israeli occupation
  • Palestinians unfairly hit by Israeli policy in Gaza
  • Double standards and cowardice still guide Western diplomacy
  • Will the Palestinian Authority be there to greet the “freedom” boats when they reach Gaza?
  • Blocking a Gazan's path to San Diego
  • Free Gaza
  • Israeli investigation of assault on Palestinian journalist Mohammed Omer a whitewash
  • Photo story: Gazans forced back to the Middle Ages
  • Voyage of the 'Little People' shames self-righteous West
  • Israel's outposts seal death of Palestinian state
  • Sailing into Gaza
  • Israeli PR fails the “decent, honest and truthful” test
  • Palestinian village faces army reign of terror
  • Israelis hinder academic pursuits
  • Israel turns Gaza into prison for Palestinian scholars
  • Israel must rein in settler movement, protect Palestinian children
  • A new initiative for ending the Israeli occupation...
  • Israel's dark arts of ensnaring collaborators
  • Israeli apartheid in action
  • Keeping the sea-lane to Gaza open permanently
  • A notional interview with Paul McCartney
  • Will fair Britannia be rescued from wicked baron’s tower?
  • Archaeology becomes a curse for Jerusalem's Palestinians
  • Israel’s breeding ground for Jewish terrorism
  • Logic of the Dark Ages
  • Israel’s “city of coexistence” shows its true colours
  • Israel “brand” will magically smell sweeter
  • Tractatus Logico Palestinicus
  • Israel bars visit to father’s grave
  • Israeli murder of 47 in Kafr Qassem commemorated
  • Israel’s travesty of tolerance on display
  • Land thieves
  • Israel tightens chokehold on village of entrepreneurs
  • The real goal of Israel’s blockade of Gaza
  • Who will stop the settlers?
  • Gaza’s Grim Reaper
  • Hebron settlers take their fight into Israel
  • Arab town blamed for Jewish Pride march’s cancellation
  • Spot the difference
  • World leaders sing the praise of fruitless peace talks
  • Oh, come all ye faithful…
  • Hamas will not be shaken by Israeli war crimes
  • Can there be any doubt who the real terrorists are?
  • What is Israel's goal in Gaza?
  • Self-defence
  • Israel’s lie machine working flat out to dodge “killer” question
  • Palestinians – write your history
  • The real goal of the slaughter in Gaza
  • Keep your eye on the ball – the slaughter in Gaza is not about rockets
  • Molten lead
  • Profile of Sderot
  • Speak out against the slaughter in Gaza
  • The nucleus of evil
  • Israel's new war ethic
  • Israel’s propaganda mainstay, Sderot, is a lie (like everything else)
  • Israel’s aim is to make the Gazan prison even more secure
  • Palestinians will never forget
  • Criticism of Israel's war crimes mounts
  • Revise terror list – de-classify Hamas and move forward
  • How many divisions?
  • Blueprint for Gaza attack was long planned
  • “Our humanity is incomplete,” says Queen Rania
  • Israel bars Arab parties from election
  • Could the rising anger of British MPs over Gaza shake America’s complacency?
  • Gaza 2009: betrayal and cowardice brought us to this
  • Israeli assault injures 1.5 million Gazans
  • In Gaza our love for God is in “intensive care”
  • How to sell “ethical warfare”
  • From diet to shoah
  • Israel’s doctrine of destruction
  • Gaza’s pastor speaks of his people’s suffering at Israel’s hands
  • Ritual murder in Gaza
  • Stripping Palestinians of their right to self-defence
  • Black flag
  • Did the Israeli army wage a Jewish jihad in Gaza?
  • Israeli university welcomes “war crimes” colonel
  • Still patting the Mad Dog?
  • Divesting from Israel’s “weapon of mass destruction”
  • “Salt of the earth” send aid convoy to Gaza while Brown sends the Royal Navy to help lawless Israel
  • Be fair to Hamas, Mr Obama
  • The only Palestinian woman in Israel’s parliament
  • Israel’s military Mephistopheles
  • Remember Ophira?
  • Palestinian villages become Israel’s playground
  • Thank you, George Galloway
  • Bedouin baby’s power struggle with Israel
  • Israel’s Occupation
  • Turkey’s fallout with Israel deals blow to settlers
  • Wake up, Christians, or lose the Holy Land
  • Avigdor Lieberman, Israel's shame
  • Biberman & Co
  • Remembering Land Day
  • Changing the rules of war
  • Palestinian student foils Israeli bid to wreck family’s education hopes
  • Israel on trial
  • Who’s the boss?
  • Israel Railways accused of racism over sacked Arab guards
  • Shattering the myth of democracy and equality in Israel
  • Let’s skip Gaza: Pope’s PR blunder
  • Law and justice first, Mr Mitchell. Peace comes later
  • Thanks, Palestinians, for St George!
  • Piracy off the promised land
  • What kind of democracy is that?
  • The emperor’s old clothes
  • Farewell to Gaza’s courageous priest
  • Israeli activist to be jailed for caring – unless the world protests
  • Ghada Karmi exposes Israeli racism
  • Pope’s “pilgrimage” mired in politics
  • Quarrel on the Titanic
  • How many secret prisons does Israel have?
  • Can Obama meet Netanyahu's challenge?
  • Netanyahu adviser moves out of the shadows
  • When will world leaders show “cruel racists” zero tolerance?
  • Calm voice, big stick
  • “If you want peace, prepare for war”
  • “Racists for Democracy”
  • The futility of pursuing a two-state Israeli-Palestinian solution
  • Where are the missing settlers?
  • Forget “negotiations”, Obama: the situation cries out for law and justice
  • Jewish town in Galilee demands “loyalty oath”
  • “The victim is the guilty party”: 12 Israeli Arabs indicted over Jewish gunman’s death
  • Israeli Premier Netanyahu’s media manipulations
  • All in a day’s work for the Israeli army: beating and torturing children
  • Canadian ambassador to Israel honoured at illegal park
  • Israel’s Holocaust reparations swindle
  • Israeli doctors colluding in torture
  • Netanyahu reaffirms commitment to racism and expansionism – thanks to US tax dollars
  • Israel calls on Jewish fanatics to “save” Galilee from its own Arab citizens
  • The two-state solution, Israeli-style
  • The Johnny procedure
  • Israel offers Palestinians day shoppers, not statehood
  • Internet surfers paid to spread Israeli propaganda
  • Israel’s Netanyahu lies to fend off Obama’s pressure
  • Can an “Arab soul” yearn for Israel’s anthem?
  • Israel seeks ways to silence human rights groups
  • Israel’s school apartheid highlighted by court case
  • Israel begins sell-off of refugees’ land
  • US turns blind eye to Israel's new separation policy
  • The IDF – Israel's organ grinder
  • The first Israeli Jew in Fatah’s parliament
  • Boycott, divestment and sanctions against Israel now urgent – Israeli academic
  • Israeli fascism: the “Bogie” Ya’alon horror show
  • The long struggle to reclaim Beersheva’s Great Mosque
  • Israel turns up the heat to evict Bedouin from desert lands
  • The travelling music is always the same
  • Prof Yehuda Hiss: the missing link in Palestinian organ theft?
  • Palestinian embassy in London strangely silent as Israeli terror-strikes and land-grabs continue
  • Israeli advertisements warn against marrying non-Jews
  • Israel’s Arab citizens call general strike in response to wave of “racist” measures
  • Israel blocks money to Gaza’s disabled
  • Branded “an enemy of Palestine” – should I laugh or cry?
  • How low will Israel stoop to win the propaganda war?
  • The not-so-hidden persuaders
  • How US tax breaks fund Israeli settlers
  • UN General Assembly president “frustrated” in his attempts to end blockade of Gaza
  • Israel’s fear of Jewish girls dating Arabs
  • On Palestinian civil disobedience
  • The comic genius of Binyamin Netanyahu
  • Binyamin Netanyahu’s UN speech: the pathology of evil
  • Gaza peace protester is prisoner in own home
  • Goldstone report's fate sealed by threats to Palestinian economy
  • Deception, spin and lies
  • “Silly season” fatwa
  • Israeli police don Arab disguise: notorious army method to be used inside Israel
  • Self-defence stories from Gaza
  • “Where have all the friendships gone...”
  • How the “most moral army in the world” wages war on students
  • Time for Britain to make amends for crimes against Palestine
  • A line in the sand: Barack Obama’s treachery in the Middle East
  • Spotlight on Palestine: an interview with Stuart Littlewood
  • The United Nations should acknowledge Palestine’s statehood
  • “Campus Watch” copycats close in on Israeli professors
  • Arab teens need “protecting from Israeli justice”
  • NATO had better steer clear of Israel
  • Have Israeli spies infiltrated international airports?
  • What festive cheer will the West bring to the Holy Land this Christmas?
  • “...And a little child shall lead them”
  • Israel’s Arab women workers need not apply
  • Israel’s notorious Hannibal procedure: army directive behind shooting of mental patient
  • Rules of human decency apply to Israelis too
  • Spot the difference: Israel’s Prussian heritage – and destiny?
  • Israeli-style “justice” for Palestinian student Berlanty – official version
  • Israeli war crimes suspect says quest for justice is for losers
  • Partition in Palestine is still the issue
  • Egypt’s President Mubarak blows his chance to behave decently
  • Gaza's untold story
  • Reaching the Gates of Hell is not so easy
  • Tactics of desperation: using false accusations of “anti-Semitism” as a weapon to silence criticism of Israel’s behaviour
  • Egypt lacks the milk of human kindness
  • The Iron Wall
  • Gaza robbed of the most basic human right: the right to health
  • Spiteful Mubarak succeeds only in creating a PR disaster for Egypt and himself
  • What next, Viva Palestina?
  • Truth will prevail: Israel panicking as the truth catches up with it
  • Israel's new rocket defence system
  • Gaza: what are promises of humanitarian aid worth?
  • In memory of Martin Luther King
  • The Liebarak
  • “Lost tribe” on fast track to Israel
  • Barack Obama’s paralysis in face of Zionist lobby
  • Arab politicians face tide of “persecution” in Israel
  • Israel stole 2 billion dollars from Palestinian workers: 40-year deception exposed
  • Israel’s war on protest: army used to deport activists against Apartheid Wall
  • Losing patience with squabbling “two-rump” Palestine
  • Sex, lies and videotape
  • Jews-only homes for Ajami
  • Israel’s re-branding exercise in Haiti backfires as past catches up
  • The long arm of Israel must be amputated
  • The new McCarthyism in Israel
  • Mossad’s murderous reach: the larger political issues
  • Do you have to be Jewish to report on Israel for the New York Times?
  • “Peace or apartheid” are not the only options for Israel
  • The truth about Israel as only Gideon Levy can tell it
  • Is Europe planning seal of approval for Israeli settlers?
  • Does Israel hope to spark a new wave of suicide bombing?
  • Rachel Corrie family finally puts Israel in dock
  • The decline of Israel and the prospects for peace
  • Israel’s “No renting to Arabs” policy
  • Israelis unhappy with weak loyalty of “British dogs”
  • Israel’s provocation at al-Aqsa
  • “By way of deception, thou shalt do war”
  • Samson and the second Nakba: a short history of the Jewish Hercules
  • Israel unveils “green” strategy to defeat enemies
  • Palestine's "turbulent priest" delivers a blistering Easter message
  • The so-called “only democracy in the Middle East”
  • Israel and the “delegitimization” oxymoron
  • The Palestinians are winning the legitimacy war: will it matter?
  • Israel: total boycott against total occupation
  • Rule by law or defiance
  • Reversing Israel’s faux legitimacy
  • Was Israel ever legitimate?
  • Israel and the question of legitimacy
  • The dark underbelly of Israel's security state
  • Mossad operation threatened against reporter
  • Did banned media report foretell of Gaza war crimes?
  • Israel’s Stasi watch over imams
  • Not much time remains for Israel – film review
  • Israel’s red line: real democracy
  • US funds Israel’s apartheid roads plan
  • Israel’s rebranding strategy focuses on delegitimizing critics and opponents
  • Israeli public sector's door closed to Arab workers
  • Even picnics in Israel are political
  • Israel’s bomb out of the shadows
  • Gaza humanitarian flotilla versus Israel’s evil navy
  • Israeli butchery at sea
  • Criminal pirate Israel makes a fool of the OECD only days after it clasped the viper to its bosom
  • The concentration camp that is Gaza
  • The madness of arrogance: Israel's attack on the Gaza aid flotilla
  • Israeli MP’s terror on aid ship: “Plan was to kill activists and deter future convoys”
  • Pirates in the Mediterranean: Israel’s shameful justification for murdering peace activists
  • “Mad dog” diplomacy: a cornered Israel is baring its teeth
  • Sea blockade of Gaza was “temporary” – 15 years ago
  • Is Israel planning act of desperation? It still holds two stolen nukes for possible port attack
  • “No citizenship without loyalty!”
  • Rise people, rise: call for zero tolerance of Israeli crimes
  • What legitimacy does Israel have?
  • You’re talking bollox, Mr Regev
  • Israeli MP who joined flotilla faces witch-hunt
  • An open letter to the Israeli Jewish public: support the Gaza Flotilla!
  • Israel's Gaza blockade: letting the chips fall where they may
  • Israel plans dig at burial place of Prophet Muhammad’s companions and Saladin warriors
  • The Israel/Palestine one-state solution sounds like a good idea, but...
  • Cutting through the confusion about Israel/Palestine
  • “Let them eat coriander!” Blockade “eased” as Gaza starves more slowly
  • Letters from Palestine: a must-read book
  • Lieberman’s “peace" plan: strip Palestinians of citizenship
  • Jerusalem politicians face expulsion by Israeli occupation authorities
  • Boycott Israel campaign wants Israel to abide by international law
  • Witch-hunt begins in Israeli schools and colleges
  • Israel's new “video game” executions
  • Israel’s parliamentary mob
  • Netanyahu: I deceived US to destroy Oslo accords
  • This Time We Went Too Far: review of Norman Finkelstein’s book on Israel’s Gaza blitzkrieg
  • Israel’s secret police exposed
  • Ethnic cleansing in the Israeli Negev
     
    Separate but unequal in Palestine

    The road to apartheid

    By Mohammed Khatib

    29 November 2007

    Mohammed Khatib fears that the process begun at Annapolis between Israel and Mahmud Abbas may allow Israel to retain Jewish settlements and Jews-only roads on the West Bank and thus lock Palestinians into a "separate but unequal" position.

    On the eve of the meeting intended to restart negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians at Annapolis, Maryland, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert announced that Israel will build no new West Bank settlements, but will not "strangle" existing Israel settlements. This means that construction in the 149 existing Israeli settlements throughout the West Bank that are strangling Palestinians, including the settlements on our village's land, will continue unchecked. Olmert's cynical announcement underlines our fear that Israel, with US support, will insist on retaining most West Bank settlements in the upcoming negotiations, locking Palestinians into a "separate but unequal" position.

    When United States Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice visited the Middle East a few weeks ago, people from our small village of Bil'in joined neighbouring villages to send her a message. We protested peacefully against a West Bank highway near us that is reserved for Jewish Israeli settlers, and off-limits to Palestinians, though it was built on Palestinian land. Our banner read: "Condi, What would Rosa Parks do?"

    We know that Dr Rice experienced the bitter taste of discrimination while growing up in the South during the US civil rights struggle. In Bil'in, we've drawn inspiration from the US civil rights movement as we've carried out a three year nonviolent resistance campaign against the discriminatory policies of Israel's military occupation.

    We share Dr Rice's admiration for the courage of Rosa Parks who was arrested in Alabama, Rice's home state, for refusing to give her bus seat to a white man. As Palestinians, we aren't even allowed in buses on many roads in our own country, because 200 miles of the best West Bank roads are reserved for Israeli Jewish settlers. [Click here for more details.] The colour of Palestinian license plates is different from the licenses of Israelis. Palestinian plates are not allowed on most of the highways crisscrossing the West Bank, many of which were built with US government funding. Palestinians have been banned for five years now from Highway 443 where we protested.

    According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), there are 561 physical obstacles and checkpoints inside the West Bank restricting Palestinian movement within the West Bank, in comparison with only eight checkpoints which separate the West Bank from Israel proper. [Click here for more details.] Nearly all the obstacles and checkpoints are located along the West Bank roads reserved for Israelis. This makes getting to the hospital, school and work or visiting relatives painstakingly difficult or impossible for us. This fragmentation of the West Bank has devastated our economy.

    For Palestinians, accepting a state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip on just 22 per cent of our historic homeland was already a dramatic compromise. But President Bush promised Israel in 2004 that in any negotiated agreement with the Palestinians Israel would retain its "already existing major population centres" in the West Bank.

    However, all Israeli settlements are illegal under international law. By annexing to Israel strategically located clusters of settlements, or "settlement blocs", and their highways which carve Palestinian areas into isolated enclaves, Israel will gain permanent control of our movement, borders, water, and cut us off from Jerusalem.

    The Israeli organization Peace Now reported a few weeks ago that the population growth rate in the settlements is three times the growth rate within Israel. [Click here for more details.] We're experiencing such rapid settlement construction around Bil'in and throughout the West Bank that I can't even find an accurate map of the West Bank for my son.

    In 2001, Israeli developers began building settlement homes on land seized from Bil'in, calling them a neighbourhood of the Modi'in Illit settlement bloc. Four years later, Israel's segregation wall separated Bil'in from 50 per cent of our agricultural land under the pretext of protecting this new settlement. In response, we held over 200 nonviolent protests together with Israeli and international supporters. Hundreds of us were injured and arrested. After our protests, Israel's Supreme Court ruled that the wall's route in Bil'in must be changed to return around half of our seized land. Though we celebrated this success, Israel continues to build on our land that wasn't returned and plans to annex it as part of the Modi'in Illit settlement bloc. [Click here for more details.]

    Israel has already de facto annexed the 10.2 per cent of the West Bank that lies between the Green Line and the segregation wall, including the major settlement blocs and 80 per cent of Israel's 450,000 settlers. The segregation wall, settlements and settlement roads carve Palestinian areas into isolated enclaves .

    We pray that our children will not spend their lives under Israeli military occupation. We hope that the Annapolis meeting will bring our dreams of freedom closer to fulfillment. But we are concerned that if Israel is allowed to keep most of its settlements and the roads that connect them, then the existing system of "separate but unequal" will be cemented in place in a Palestinian state.



    Mohammed Khatib is a leading member of Bilin's Popular Committee Against the Wall and the secretary of its village council.


    Copyright © Redress Information & Analysis.
    All rights reserved.